Non Traditional Engagement Rings

Men's and gender neutral wedding bands on anna sheffield's handmade objects dish

Non Traditional Engagement Rings

Our non-traditional engagement rings celebrate individuality and the beauty of personal expression. Featuring alternative gemstones and intricate cluster ring designs, each piece is a work of art crafted with meaning and care. Our rings are ethically sourced, heirloom-quality and often customizable, offering a thoughtful alternative to conventional styles. Select an eccentric wedding band or explore alternative engagement rings with this collection, where every design tells a unique story: yours.

Skip to results list
74 items
Sort Featured
Column grid
Column grid

Filter

Sort Featured
  • Toi Et Moi Ring - Yellow Gold, Grey & White Diamond (2.27ct)
    One-of-a-kind

    Toi Et Moi Ring - Yellow Gold, Grey & White Diamond (2.27ct)

    Toi Et Moi Ring

    Yellow Gold, Grey & White Diamond (2.27ct)

  • Toi Et Moi Ring - Yellow Gold, Champagne & White Diamond (1.53ct)
    One-of-a-kind

    Toi Et Moi Ring - Yellow Gold, Champagne & White Diamond (1.53ct)

    Toi Et Moi Ring

    Yellow Gold, Champagne & White Diamond (1.53ct)

  • Hazeline Solitaire Ring - 14k Gold & Grey Diamond

    Hazeline Solitaire Ring - 14k Gold & Grey Diamond

    Hazeline Solitaire Ring

    14k Gold & Grey Diamond

    From $6,800.00 USD
  • Hazeline Suite No. 35

    Hazeline Suite No. 35

    Hazeline Suite No. 35

    From $18,550.00 USD
  • Hazeline Three Stone Ring - 14k Gold & Grey Diamond (1.00ct)

    Hazeline Three Stone Ring - 14k Gold & Grey Diamond (1.00ct)

    Hazeline Three Stone Ring

    14k Gold & Grey Diamond (1.00ct)

    $7,300.00 USD
  • Creo Ring - Yellow Gold & Lab White Diamond (1.54ct)
    READY-TO-SHIP

    Creo Ring - Yellow Gold & Lab White Diamond (1.54ct)

    Creo Ring

    Yellow Gold & Lab White Diamond (1.54ct)

    $7,500.00 USD
    Ready to Ship
  • Butterfly Chrysalis Ring - 14k Yellow Gold & Champagne Diamond (1.05ct)
    READY-TO-SHIP

    Butterfly Chrysalis Ring - 14k Yellow Gold & Champagne Diamond (1.05ct)

    Butterfly Chrysalis Ring

    14k Yellow Gold & Champagne Diamond (1.05ct)

    $9,520.00 USD
    Ready to Ship
  • Theda Ring - Yellow Gold & Rose Cut Oval Champagne Diamond (1.85ct)

    Theda Ring - Yellow Gold & Rose Cut Oval Champagne Diamond (1.85ct)

    Theda Ring

    Yellow Gold & Rose Cut Oval Champagne Diamond (1.85ct)

  • Theda Ring - Yellow Gold & Lozenge Champagne Diamond (1.51ct)
    One-of-a-kind

    Theda Ring - Yellow Gold & Lozenge Champagne Diamond (1.51ct)

    Theda Ring

    Yellow Gold & Lozenge Champagne Diamond (1.51ct)

  • Theda Ring - Yellow Gold & Emerald Cut Black Diamond (2.05ct)

    Theda Ring - Yellow Gold & Emerald Cut Black Diamond (2.05ct)

    Theda Ring

    Yellow Gold & Emerald Cut Black Diamond (2.05ct)

  • Bea Three Stone Ring - Rose Gold & Black Diamond (7x5mm)
    READY-TO-SHIP

    Bea Three Stone Ring - Rose Gold & Black Diamond (7x5mm)

    Bea Three Stone Ring

    Rose Gold & Black Diamond (7x5mm)

    $7,200.00 USD
    Select Options Ready to Ship
  • Bea Suite No. 06

    Bea Suite No. 06

    Bea Suite No. 06

    From $11,970.00 USD
  • Bea Three Stone Ring - 14k Gold & Black Diamond
    MOST LOVED

    Bea Three Stone Ring - 14k Gold & Black Diamond

    Bea Three Stone Ring

    14k Gold & Black Diamond

    From $6,850.00 USD
  • Theda Hex Ring - Yellow Gold & Black Diamond & Grey Diamond (3.13ct)

    Theda Hex Ring - Yellow Gold & Black Diamond & Grey Diamond (3.13ct)

    Theda Hex Ring

    Yellow Gold & Black Diamond & Grey Diamond (3.13ct)

  • Theda Hex Ring - Yellow Gold & Yellow Diamond (1.57ct)

    Theda Hex Ring - Yellow Gold & Yellow Diamond (1.57ct)

    Theda Hex Ring

    Yellow Gold & Yellow Diamond (1.57ct)

  • Marquise Bea Ring - 14k Gold & Black Diamond (1.25ct)
    MOST LOVED

    Marquise Bea Ring - 14k Gold & Black Diamond (1.25ct)

    Marquise Bea Ring

    14k Gold & Black Diamond (1.25ct)

    $7,110.00 USD
  • Marquise Bea Halo Ring - 14k Gold & Black Diamond (14x7mm)

    Marquise Bea Halo Ring - 14k Gold & Black Diamond (14x7mm)

    Marquise Bea Halo Ring

    14k Gold & Black Diamond (13x6.5mm)

    $10,150.00 USD
  • Bea East/West Solitaire Ring - 14k Gold & Black Diamond (7x5mm)

    Bea East/West Solitaire Ring - 14k Gold & Black Diamond (7x5mm)

    Bea East/West Solitaire Ring

    14k Gold & Black Diamond (7x5mm)

    $4,300.00 USD
  • Bea Five Stone Ring - 14k Gold, Black Diamond & White Diamonds
    BEST SELLER

    Bea Five Stone Ring - 14k Gold, Black Diamond & White Diamonds

    Bea Five Stone Ring

    14k Gold, Black Diamond & White Diamonds

    $3,340.00 USD
  • Hazeline Solitaire Ring - 14k Gold & Black Diamond
    Best Seller

    Hazeline Solitaire Ring - 14k Gold & Black Diamond

    Hazeline Solitaire Ring

    14k Gold & Black Diamond

    From $3,350.00 USD
  • Hazeline Three Stone Ring - 14k Gold & Black Diamond (1.00ct)
    Best Seller

    Hazeline Three Stone Ring - 14k Gold & Black Diamond (1.00ct)

    Hazeline Three Stone Ring

    14k Gold & Black Diamond (1.00ct)

    $5,785.00 USD
  • Hazeline Suite No. 11

    Hazeline Suite No. 11

    Hazeline Suite No. 11

    From $6,935.00 USD
  • Bea Suite No. 11

    Bea Suite No. 11

    Bea Suite No. 11

    From $13,215.00 USD
  • Bea Three Stone Ring - Yellow Gold & Black Diamond (5.55ct)

    Bea Three Stone Ring - Yellow Gold & Black Diamond (5.55ct)

    Bea Three Stone Ring

    Yellow Gold & Black Diamond (5.55ct)

CUSTOM & BESPOKE ENGAGEMENT RINGS

Uniquely Yours

Looking for something as unique as your love story? Learn more about the Custom & Bespoke engagement ring program, where you can make your ring dreams come true down to the smallest detail, all done remotely or by visiting our NYC store. Learn more or book an appointment today.

Learn More >

Frequently Asked Questions

Learn more about Non-Traditional Engagement Rings

Are non-traditional engagement rings suitable for weddings?

Absolutely. A non-traditional ring is just as meaningful and appropriate as a traditional engagement ring when it comes to celebrating love and commitment. Whether paired with a wedding ring or standing alone, these distinctive pieces often hold deeper symbolism and better reflect the wearer's individuality. From vintage engagement rings to modern alternative styles, non-traditional rings make unforgettable choices for today’s weddings.

Can I design my own non-traditional engagement ring with Anna Sheffield?

Yes. At Anna Sheffield, we offer custom engagement ring services to help you create a one-of-a-kind piece. From selecting alternative gemstones to crafting a diamond ring in mixed metals or inspired by vintage engagement rings, our bespoke process allows you to bring your vision to life. We’ll guide you through choosing the perfect setting, stone and ring size to create a non-traditional ring that tells your unique story.

Are the materials used ethically sourced and sustainable?

Anna Sheffield is deeply committed to sustainability and ethical sourcing in every piece of fine jewelry. We use recycled gold, conflict-free diamonds and reclaimed melΓ©e to ensure your diamond engagement ring or non-traditional ring is crafted responsibly. Our practices reflect a dedication to both artistry and environmental responsibility, so you can feel confident that your alternative engagement ring is as conscientious as it is beautiful.

More FAQ's